Franz G Co (
Tue, 27 Mar 2001 21:16:32 -0500 (EST)

------Original Message------
From: "CHIN, Chien Ting" <>
To: <>
Sent: March 26, 2001 10:35:18 PM GMT
Subject: Re: [gundam]Plot holes in 08MST

>Ehh... spoiler alerts...

Echo|Fox wrote:
>> Where to begin?
>> 08MST is one of my favorite Gundam series, but it is riddled >with
>> continuity busting plot points.
>> They key one being the large number (16?) of RX-79[G] Gundam >Groundtypes
>> running around Earth. I just don't see how they can possible >rationalize
>> their existence, given that the RX-78 was just a prototype >and the GM's
>> were even newer. Just ... wierd. As someone mentioned the >last time this
>> was brought up, it would have been cooler, IMHO, if >the "Gundams" in
>> were just GM's with v-fins and faceplates bolted on to >confuse the Zeon
>> forces... sort of fake Gundams if you will.

>Well all the UC OVAs are continuity busters. Personally I've >heard all I
>care about the geneology of NT1, Gundam Groud Type and the GP >series.
>Continuity breakages of these kind are not very interesting to >me, because
>they are partly intentional.

>Let's think about internal plot holes, and there are a few in >08MST.

>Was the Ez8 a better MS than RX-79[G]? If so, how come Shiro->the-most-
>distrusted-soldier-in-the-whole-goddamn-army gets assigned to >it?

It had a better thrust-to-weight ratio that's for sure since it's lighter
and it supposedly has better armor arrangement (thicker where it needs to be
- namely front).

>How come Ginias started shooting BEFORE the Zanzibar get to a >safe

He was psycho! Actually, it was Aina who started shooting, she was a "bit"
angry at Norris' death.

>How come Eledore and Michel received no disipline after going >AWOL and
>risking his commander's ass?

Probably due to Nickerd's connections, he probably gave them fake papers to
say they were ordered to go scout.

>How come Michel, a nice decent guy but a lousy soldier, got >assigned to
>a position in one of the very few MS teams?

Lack of people I guess.

>Most importantly, after the court martial, why did the brass >send Shiro on
>a mission on the final assault? If his team was used as a >sacrifical
>diversion (as one line of dialogue vaguely suggested), how come >he ended
>up escorting those Guntanks, one of the most critical part of >the assault?

Hmm... maybe Lyer changed his mind. Maybe he thought that if Shiro was a
spy, he would cause havoc in the mine breaching operations.

>Dr. Core
>Brain Surgeon
>Newtype Asylum

Gundam Mailing List Archives are available at

Shop through Barnes and Nobles
help me earn cash too.
FREE Personalized Email at
Sign up at

Gundam Mailing List Archives are available at

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.0b3 on Wed Mar 28 2001 - 11:16:53 JST