Franz G Co (
Sat, 10 Mar 2001 09:04:28 -0500 (EST)

------Original Message------
From: "L. M. Lloyd" <>
To: <>
Sent: March 10, 2001 9:43:27 AM GMT
Subject: RE: [gundam] MSG's animation and its North American debut

Hash: SHA1

>I think there might be some anti Japanese sentiment at the root >of
>it, but also remember that, for right or wrong, Americans tend >to
>feel that they own the animation market. I mean, Disney, Warner
>Bros., MGM, Hanna Barbarra, Ralf Bakshi, and more recently >Pixar, all

Hmm, Pixar, I wonder if they feel threatened by the Final Fantasy Movie as
well as the recent CG that we've seen from some Japanese games lately.

>cause Americans to feel that they are the animation standard >that
>everyone has to measure up to.

>As an animator myself, I can say emphatically that 90% of the
>arguments for why Japanese animation is of poorer quality than
>American animation, are nothing but a load of crap. People like >to do
>things like compare a Disney feature film, to a Sunrise TV

Let's them compare any Disney film with something like Grave of the
Fireflies. IT seems that ppl tend to focus on the animation, what about the

>and that is in no way, shape, or form a valid comparison. If you
>compare a show like Cowboy BeBop, or Betterman to a show like
>Animaniacs or Batman, you quickly see that anime has a far >higher
>line count, better shading, more lighting effects, a broader >range of
>character design work as well as expression, and an average >frame
>count within 1 to 3 frames a second of American shows. >Unfortunately
>the comparisons done in the US are always something asinine >like Lion
>King vs. Pokemon!

>Oh well, the joys of being an American. I just wish that the >rest of
>the world could understand how much tolerance you have to have >to be
>an American, but not one of the flag waving, follow-the-heard >types.
>Some of us really are intelligent, nice people.

Shop through Barnes and Nobles
help me earn cash too.
FREE Personalized Email at
Sign up at

Gundam Mailing List Archives are available at

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.0b3 on Sat Mar 10 2001 - 23:04:37 JST