Roland Thigpen (
17 Oct 2000 16:17:57 -0000

On Tue, 17 Oct 2000 09:00:39 -0700 (PDT) garrick lee <> wrote:
>--- wrote:
>> People said that about Macross II before it was
>> banned from the continuinty
>> if I remembered correctly...
>yeah, but you can't ban gundam wing from it's own
>timeline. :) and since gundam wing is proudly
>alternate timeline in the first place, what would
>banning it from the UC timeline do, besides stroking
>the insecure egos of the legions of ranting wing
>people get too huffy about what is and what isn't
>gundam (or insert favorite rave show) for their own

That's why I don't have any problems with Wing as such. I just didn't feel as satisfied as I do when watching UC. Hell, I loved Wing when it first came out as it was new Gundam I hadn't seen before. But after watching it for some time, I find I just don't have the appreciation for it that I do for UC stuff.

>i'm probably as die-hard a macross fan as many here
>are UC gundam fans. i didn't like mac2 all that
>much, but i don't bitch about macross 2 being a
>rip-off. i think the guitar-piloting in mac7 is all
>screwy, but i don't whine about macross 7 destroying
>the top-gun image of macross like many self-proclaimed
>purist bastards (how i hate people like those) are
>wont to. it's just too...pathetic to do so.

Macross II was another series that I thought effectively took another story and made it just different enough to be interesting. Some of the characters are a little weird, but it is enjoyable. Plus, you almost just have to love Fairy Squadron. And I LOVE Macross 7.

>i've had enough of "that's not what gundam (or insert
>favorite rave show) is supposed to be!" to last me an
>eternity of suffering. i doth think people bash
>alternate timeline gundams too much. gee, i wonder

Agreed. Especially from those who blast BGC Tokyo 2040 and Macross 7.

>at any rate, i think macross 2 music blends in quite
>well with macross 7 music. macross plus music was
>just another monstrosity entirely, and i don't care if
>it's yoko kano composition.

Guess that is why they had the Sound Jammers playing Macross II music in combat in Macross 7. As for Macross Plus, I liked it. What did you have problems with? Just for curiousities sake.


Get Email, News, Links and The Best Selection at

Gundam Mailing List Archives are available at

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.0b3 on Wed Oct 18 2000 - 01:22:39 JST