Rodrick Su (
Sun, 28 May 2000 22:45:45 -0700

> -----Original Message-----
> From: []On
> Behalf Of -Z-
> Sent: Sunday, May 28, 2000 1:46 PM
> To:
> Subject: Re: [gundam] 0083 Colony Drop
> At 09:35 5/28/2000, you wrote:
> >At 17:14 05/27/2000 MST, Blackeagle wrote:
> >>We've been talking about colony drops here, and it brings up a
> question
> I've
> >>had for a while. In 0083, why didn't the Federation use a
> nuke to blow up
> >>the falling colony rather than trying the cumbersome and
> vunerable Solar
> >>System?
> >
> > Possible reasons: No reliable delivery systems. After
> all, the GP02A
> >is already destroyed. Will there be sufficient missiles, etc.
> in the right
> >positions to launch enough not only to get through the screening MSes as
> >well as to destroy the colony?
> >
> > Politics: Maybe the proto-Titans don't even want the
> colony to stop.
> >They have to make an attempt, of course, but the end effect of the Delaz
> >colony is a dramatic increase of the Titans' powers.
> Maybe the just didn't have that many nuclear weapons left, having
> expended
> most of them during the first week of the One Year War and being
> loathe to
> build that particular part of the arsenal back up thereafter.

Not when you consider how many nukes were used in Char's Counterattack.
Cameron Bloom slipped a boat load of nukes in Bright Noah's hand because he
rightly didn't trust Char's intention. Char also stole a whole bunch of
nukes from Luna 2.

> >>1: The Federation doesn't have nuclear weapons powerful enough
> to break
> up a
> >>40km long colony.
> >
> > Given the power of the Mk. 82 that Gato used on the Review, one
> >won't be possible to destroy the colony. Maybe a few is needed. But why
> >destroy the colony? Use a few to nudge the colony off course.
> The Mk.82 is a TACTICAL nuclear weapon. Compare that to the STRATEGIC
> nuclear weapon that Killing intended to use against Side 6, which
> looked a
> lot more like a contemporary ICBM. The Mk.82 is intended for use on a
> battlefield against ships and MS, which it did quite neatly. A
> missile of
> the type that Killing carried would've probably taken
> Solomon/Konpei Island
> out altogether.

Hum... Solomon is a big piece of rock. Even modern day nukes will be hard
press to put a dent in a big rock. Now, a hollowed cylander like a colony,
no problem at all. As you were found of saying, the big problem with a
colony drop is not the "land" and "glass" piece, but the endpiece, which is
likely the only piece that can withstand re-entry to cause serious damage.
Stragetic nukes should be able to handle that.

> Whatever you use, deflecting the colony has to be your goal. Breaking it
> into pieces without changing their trajectory and orbital velocity will
> only result in lots of small pieces rather than one big one. Yes, you
> might be able to blast it into such small pieces that they all
> burned up in
> the atmosphere, but the odds are that you'd still end up with dozens of
> pieces large enough to do major damage.

Yeah, instead of getting everything to hit it in one location, you now have
2 end piece hitting different location.

[ Rodrick Su [ ]
[ [ I might be crazier than you think. ]

NetZero - Defenders of the Free World
Click here for FREE Internet Access and Email

Gundam Mailing List Archives are available at

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.0b3 on Mon May 29 2000 - 14:35:16 JST