garrick lee (
Mon, 27 Sep 1999 07:01:23 -0700 (PDT)

> You said I'm a bit close minded, well yes in a
> certain way. The stories
> from UC timelines are very deep and that can appeal
> to the older audience.
> The new spinoffs (not counting turn A since they
> weren't done by Tomino)
> just didn't have the good stories to catch the older
> and more mature
> generation. The content and subject matter int these
> new spinoffs was more
> like geared towards kiddie shows. I'm not young
> anymore, so the typical
> dragonball fighting style in g-gundam just throws me
> off. long as you're not calling people who CAN
enjoy non-UC gundam childish and immature...

not to be rude, but i think this is really just a case
of bashing that which you don't enjoy. a "good" and
captivating story for you, may not be so for me and
vice versa.

how is non-UC gundam any more TRULY childish and
immature than UC? wacky and absurd, maybe, but saying
that it's geared towards kiddie viewers IS a bit of a
talk-down, no matter how you twist it. in UC, exactly
how mature and logical is it to have prepubescents
come across and pilot war machines?

gundam is a 20 year old saga, and spans at least three
different generations (people of the 70's, children of
the 80's, and generation x'ers of the 90's). but from
what i can see, it's basic themes have never varied
much, UC or non-UC. it's just the presentation. if
you look beyond it, it's underlying themes are mostly
the same.

>Turn A is
> different, yes. But let's not forget that the
> gundam designs are getting
> too repetitive and if you go to
> you'll see the authors of the site saying it was a
> breakthrough with this
> new design. It might not be Syd's best designs, but
> hey at least it's
> original, so give him a break. And for those who
> don't know Syd Mead, he
> was the guy who designed the mechanics for Blade
> Runner and Aliens(yeah kick
> ass movie). So are you telling me this guy doesn't
> know how to design??
> And it wasn't his decision to come up with a wacky
> design, if I remember
> correctly, it was Tomino's decision to come with
> such a wacky design. And
> Tomino is the man, it was his decision and I respect
> that.

well, we all respect tomino's decision. but don't we
also have a right to our own opinion on aesthetics?

if i ever get to see and like turn A series, i'm still
going to have a hard time appreciating that butt ugly
mech design.

Do You Yahoo!?
Bid and sell for free at

Gundam Mailing List Archives are available at

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.0b3 on Mon Sep 27 1999 - 22:50:05 JST